Monday, March 06, 2017

Where's the (Licit) Beef? – Amid St Pat's (Fri)Day, The Indult Desk Is Open

(SVILUPPO: Following its most recent update, the Master List now comprises a record 120-plus US dioceses – fully two-thirds of the nation's Latin-church sees.)

Just because it's Lent doesn't mean there isn't some fun to be had... and in that light, this edition of the 40 Days just so happens to bring a long-awaited return to one of this shop's favorite exercises.

Eleven years ago, among the first splashes made here was a national take on what came to be termed the The Corned Beef Indult – that is, the dispensation granted by a diocesan bishop so the Irish faithful can enjoy the patronal sandwich with a clear conscience when St Patrick's Day falls on a Lenten Friday, thus pitting the feast against the obligatory abstinence from meat.

This year marks the first collision of the two observances since, and in most cases the announcements are just beginning to bubble up, numbering over 40 so far. As history goes, in 2006 the general permission was given by nearly half of the nation's 179 Latin-church jurisdictions.

In any case, this is indeed a thing – if you will, the "Amoris Wars" for the non-chattering class (just without the invective). That the story takes on a life of its own in local media and over dinner tables is a sound testimony to two linchpin realities an "anger first" discourse seems to easily forget: first, that the identity-marker of "Fish Fridays" holds an enduring place among the faithful, with the practice maintained by close to a supermajority of American Catholicism's 70 million souls (per CARA figures)... even more significantly, meanwhile, it just goes to show again that when it comes to widespread fascination with this faith, nothing beats even the relatively minor elements of the Catholic imagination (however much Dan Brown may try).

Before going into this edition's master list of dispensed dioceses, a couple pieces of context bear recalling.

First, in those places where the Apostle of Ireland is the patron of the diocese or of the parish church, within said territory Paddymas ranks as a proper solemnity, thus exempting the obligatory abstinence from meat by the law itself. Among other examples, this is the case in New York, and was clarified as such by Cardinal Timothy Dolan in a late January letter to his priests.

To be fully specific, that general rule only applies where Patrick is patron of the diocese, not diocese-wide where he's patron of the cathedral – unless his diocesan patronal status is likewise formally in place, the cathedral's name-day only ranks as a proper feast and mandatory abstinence remains intact. (In another related instance, as St Joseph's Day and Annunciation are universal solemnities, abstinence is not observed across the Catholic world whenever March 19th or 25th fall on a Friday.)

Second, even as the bulk of the 70 million Stateside faithful will likely get the green light at the diocesan level owing to large-scale Irish populations and simple concern for the welfare of souls, it bears recalling that – in cases where a diocesan indult hasn't been granted – pastors of parishes may dispense their own people from avoiding meat given "just cause" as with any Lenten Friday; this is usually done on an individual basis by request (for example, for a parishioner attending a wedding rehearsal dinner with meat on the menu).

Just to name three, Detroit, Portland (Oregon) and Salt Lake have gone that route this year in lieu of the blanket indult, while the diocese of Trenton and archdiocese of St Louis are only granting the permissions to functions held on church property (for the latter, a notably more restrictive stance than then-Archbishop Raymond Burke took there last time). Elsewhere, keeping with their shared reputation for seeking to bolster an ironclad Catholic identity, the archdiocese of Denver and diocese of Lincoln are the lone US sees to have publicly denied granting a broad dispensation.

Thirdly, to be clear, nobody's getting off scot-free regardless of local policy – in each instance where the indult's been granted, the move is accompanied by a pro forma encouragement (albeit not an order) that abstinence should either be transferred to the prior or following day, or that some other act of penance or charity be substituted for digging into the beef. In any event, those traveling on the 17th itself are bound by the decision of the diocese in which they happen to be, not that of the place where they reside.

All that said, just because you don't see your own local church listed below doesn't mean you're out of luck – if anything, these announcements are usually made with little fanfare, or simply circulated internally to the parishes.

Ergo, as the following was initially compiled from publicly available notices, the list will be kept updated as the day approaches, so wherever a permission has been granted and isn't noted here, please do send it along – you can email it, tweet it... and given the priority on getting word around, even the combox is open. (NB: anything not germane to the topic will not be published.)

And lastly, much as keeping you lot out of Hell (at least, on this count) is its own reward, alas, that alone can't pay the bills – as ever, these pages keep afloat solely by means of your support....

*    *    *
For the commemoration of St Patrick, 17 March 2017, the following local churches are generally dispensed or granted a commutation from Lenten abstinence by act of the respective (arch)bishop or the proper solemnity of the diocesan patron – conditions/substitions may vary by jurisdiction:

All dioceses of Wisconsin and Georgia

Archdioceses of Anchorage, Baltimore, Boston, Chicago, Dubuque, Galveston-Houston, Hartford, Indianapolis, Kansas City in Kansas, Los Angeles, Louisville, Miami, The Military Services USA, Mobile, Newark, New Orleans, New York, Omaha, Philadelphia, Saint Paul and Minneapolis, San Antonio, San Francisco, Seattle, Washington DC

Dioceses of Albany, Allentown, Arlington, Austin, Baton Rouge, Beaumont, Belleville, Birmingham, Boise, Bridgeport, Brooklyn, Brownsville, Buffalo, Burlington, Camden, Charleston, Cleveland, Colorado Springs, Corpus Christi, Covington, Dallas, Davenport, Des Moines, Duluth, Erie, Fall River, Fargo, Fort Wayne-South Bend, Fort Worth, Fresno, Gary, Gaylord, Greensburg, Harrisburg, Honolulu, Jackson, Jefferson City, Joliet, Juneau, Kalamazoo, Kansas City-St Joseph, Knoxville, Lafayette (La.), Las Cruces, Las Vegas, Lexington, Manchester, Memphis, Metuchen, Nashville, Norwich, Oakland, Ogdensburg, Owensboro, Palm Beach, Paterson, Pensacola-Tallahassee, Peoria, Phoenix, Pittsburgh, Portland (Maine), Providence, Raleigh, Rochester, Rockford, Rockville Centre, Sacramento, St Augustine, St Cloud, St Petersburg, San Bernardino, San Diego, Scranton, Spokane, Springfield (Mass.), Springfield-Cape Girardeau, Steubenville, Stockton, Syracuse, Toledo, Tucson, Tyler, Venice (Florida), Victoria, Wheeling-Charleston, Wilmington, Winona, Worcester, Yakima, Youngstown


Blogger Tom Grelinger said...

Kansas City-St. Joseph diocese -

6/3/17 16:20  
Blogger paguy1976 said...

Harrisburg is also dispensed.

6/3/17 16:28  
Blogger EFOF91 said...

Dispensation from Abstinence by Bishop DiMarzio (Brooklyn)

Dispensation from Abstinence by Cardinal Tobin (Newark)

6/3/17 17:54  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I read today that both Phoenix and Tucson granted dispensations.

6/3/17 21:15  
Blogger Unknown said...

The Archdiocese of Kansas City in Kansas is also dispensed.

6/3/17 22:39  
Anonymous Msgr. Robert Siler said...

Yakima as well, with thanks to Phoenix for the suggested alternative penitential practices.

6/3/17 23:42  
Anonymous Fr John Sauer said...

Winona, MN as well.

7/3/17 07:20  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Diocese of Venice in Florida has issued a dispensation.

7/3/17 09:36  
Blogger Diakonos said...

Dispensation for Archdiocese of San Francisco...

7/3/17 10:45  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Archdiocese for the Military Services, USA is offering a dispensation

7/3/17 11:56  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

7/3/17 14:11  
Anonymous Rev B\rendan Murray said...

Bishop Serratelli granted it for Paterson

7/3/17 18:27  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Davenport, Iowa dispensed

7/3/17 23:56  
Anonymous George Richert-Buffalo Diocese said...

Bishop Richard J. Malone has granted a 'commutation of abstinence' for the Diocese of Buffalo, NY. Catholics may eat meat on March 17, but abstain on another day close to it.

8/3/17 11:34  
Blogger Larry said...

Bishop Strickland of the Diocese of Tyler, Texas, has granted a dispensation from the discipline of abstinence on March 17, on the condition that those who take advantage of the dispensation transfer the obligation to either March 16 or March 18.

8/3/17 11:35  
Anonymous Sr. Jeanne Wiest, OP said...

Bishop William Medley has granted dispensation for the Diocese of Owensboro.

8/3/17 15:37  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Diocese of Bridgeport

8/3/17 17:48  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Diocese of Boise

8/3/17 19:44  
Blogger Friar Minor SLR said...

From: Donna Daly
Sent: Tuesday, March 7, 2017 10:05 AM
To: Staff; Seminary


Office of the Bishop:
In light of the many members of our local church who are of Irish descent, and those others who are honorary Irish on the great feast of Saint Patrick, members of the diocese of San Diego are dispensed from the obligation to abstain from meat on Friday, March 17th. All those who utilize this dispensation are encouraged to choose another day of the week to abstain from meat.

9/3/17 18:25  
Anonymous Deacon Joshua LsBlanc said...

Diocese of Lafayette, LA is also dispensed for ALL Catholics

9/3/17 18:52  
Blogger Unknown said...

The Diocese of Juneau has also granted the dispensation.

14/3/17 17:09  
Blogger Dr. J said...

In Davenport abstinence is not dispensed; it is commuted to another day of the week.

14/3/17 21:34  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Diocese of Covington dispensed

15/3/17 10:38  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Fargo, ND, dispensed

15/3/17 20:34  
Blogger Fr. Horton said...

Peoria, IL dispensed

17/3/17 07:46  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Diocese of St. Augustine (FL) has granted the permission again this year. It was posted on their Facebook page:

Catholic Diocese of St. Augustine (official)
13 March at 16:07 ·
As you are well aware, this year the celebration of St. Patrick’s feast day on March 17 falls on a Friday during Lent.
In consideration of the culinary traditions of this feast and in response to a number of requests, Bishop Estévez has granted to Catholics in the Diocese of St. Augustine a dispensation from the Lenten rule of abstaining from meat on that Friday for those who choose to abstain on Saturday, March 18 instead.

17/3/17 11:04  

Post a Comment

<< Home